Operational Pipeline v0.2.0Beta Multi-model Analyzed 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
truth-bot.
President

Donald Trump

February 24, 2026·State of the Union
Mixed verdict
3 of 8 claims rated false
Truthy M.
Tap
Mixed signals — some hold up, some don't.
40%
Truthy or better
True + Truthy / all claims
40%
False or worse
False + Falsey / all claims
10
Claims Checked
4
Models Engaged
20%
Model Consensus
1
Leaders Reviewed
Strict lens
True 2
Truthy 2
Unverifiable 0
Falsey 1
False 3
Models:anthropic · gemini · openai · xai
Jump to claim10 claims evaluated
Claims, in order spokenAnchor links shareable
Claim 01 / 10 Falsey
"Trump claims the United States now has the strongest and most secure border in American history."
comparison
Model notes
  • AnthropicThe 'strongest in history' phrasing is political/hyperbolic; CBP apprehension data is reliable back only to 1960, so comparisons to all of 'American history' are not strictly verifiable.
  • OpenAITier 1 primary source retrieved from CBP, but the phrase 'strongest and most secure border in American history' is inherently subjective and not a standard government statistic.
  • GoogleNo Tier 1 primary source retrieved that provides a comprehensive historical comparison of all border security metrics. The verdict relies on Tier 1 press releases from CBP and DHS which contain both data and qualitative characterizations.
Model consensus 2 of 4 agree · 2 dissents
anthropic
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

CBP and DHS have repeatedly — and officially — characterized the border as 'the most secure border in history' throughout 2025. CBP reported that October-November-December 2025 saw the lowest fiscal-year-to-date encounter totals ever recorded (91,603 total, 25% below the previous low of 121,469 in FY2012), and FY25 USBP Southwest Border apprehensions (237,538) were the lowest level since 1970 per the House Homeland Security Committee. CBP also logged 8 consecutive months of zero releases through December 2025. While the superlative 'in American history' is contested (apprehension data only go back reliably decades, and low numbers could also reflect deterrence rather than true security), the underlying enforcement statistics strongly support the direction of the claim.

openai
📊 Exaggerated
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 5.4.2026.03.05

CBP did report historically low illegal-crossing figures during Trump’s second term—for example, on April 1, 2025 it said March 2025 had the lowest southwest border crossings in history, and on July 15, 2025 it said June 2025 had the lowest monthly total encounters in CBP history. Those official statistics support a claim of very low recent crossings, but the broader superlative that the U.S. 'now has the strongest and most secure border in American history' is not a precise, independently defined metric and goes beyond what the underlying data can conclusively prove across all eras and dimensions of border security.

gemini
📊 Exaggerated
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

The claim that the border is the "strongest and most secure in American history" is an exaggeration, though data from early 2026 shows a significant decrease in illegal crossings. In January 2026, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) reported 34,626 total encounters nationwide, with 6,070 Border Patrol apprehensions on the southwest border, a 79% decrease from January 2025. Data for the first quarter of Fiscal Year 2026 (Oct-Dec 2025) showed the lowest number of southwest border apprehensions to start a fiscal year on record. DHS and CBP officials have characterized this as "the most secure border in American history." However, the phrase "strongest and most secure in American history" is difficult to prove definitively, as historical data collection methods vary and other metrics beyond apprehensions (like got-aways, drug seizures, and resourcing) contribute to overall security. While current enforcement has led to historically low encounter numbers, calling it the most secure ever is a subjective assessment.

xai
✅ True
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

DHS and CBP reports for early 2026, including January and February data, show historically low southwest border apprehensions (e.g., 6,073 in January 2026, 96% lower than previous administration averages) and consecutive months of zero releases, with official statements describing the border as more secure than at any point in history.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 02 / 10 False
"Trump claims that in the past nine months, zero illegal aliens have been admitted to the United States."
statistical
Model notes
  • AnthropicThe claim conflates 'admitted' with 'released.' Some illegal aliens are still encountered, apprehended, and processed; the 'zero' figure refers specifically to releases into the U.S. interior. Tier 1 sources (CBP, DHS) used.
  • Grok 4Primary sources (CBP/DHS) confirm ongoing border activity; 'admitted' may imply legal entry, but context suggests zero illegal immigration, which is unsupported.
Model consensus 3 of 4 agree · 1 dissent
anthropic
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

CBP and DHS primary sources confirm that for seven consecutive months as of November 2025, U.S. Border Patrol released zero illegal aliens into the United States. CBP's December 4, 2025 release explicitly states 'For the seventh consecutive month, U.S. Border Patrol released zero illegal aliens into the United States.' However, this technically refers only to releases by Border Patrol after apprehension — illegal aliens are still being apprehended (over 117,000 enforcement encounters since January 21 through November on the southwest border) and processed under law, not 'admitted.' The streak of zero releases covers roughly seven months, not the full nine months claimed, though the broader policy of catch-and-release ended in January 2025, so 'admitted' as a term is largely supported.

openai
❌ False
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 4.1.2025.04.14

CBP and DHS data confirm that in any recent nine-month period, thousands of individuals have been admitted into the U.S. after illegal entry, including through processing at the southwest border and parole programs. Zero admissions is contradicted by official statistics for both encounter releases and border parolees.

gemini
❌ False
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

The claim that zero unauthorized immigrants have been admitted to the United States over any nine-month period is false. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) data consistently shows hundreds of thousands of encounters with individuals crossing the border each month. These encounters include apprehensions and expulsions, but also cases where individuals are deemed inadmissible or released pending immigration proceedings. CBP statistics, which are a primary source for this data, report these numbers monthly and do not show any period with zero encounters or admissions.

xai
❌ False
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

U.S. Customs and Border Protection data reports thousands of migrant encounters monthly, including illegal entries; from May 2025 to February 2026, encounters exceeded hundreds of thousands, contradicting the claim of zero illegal aliens admitted or entering the United States.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 03 / 10 Models split
"Trump claims the flow of deadly fentanyl across the U.S. border is down by a record 56 percent in one year."
statistical
Model notes
  • AnthropicSeizures are an imperfect proxy for actual fentanyl flow; declines could partly reflect changes in trafficking routes or methods. The 56% figure comes from DHS itself; independent analysis (WOLA) shows a 46% year-over-year decline.
  • GoogleThe claim is about a future period for which complete, verifiable primary source data is not yet available. Secondary sources mention the 56% figure but lack the detailed official data needed for confirmation.
  • Grok 4Flow is estimated via seizures (primary CBP/DEA data); no exact 56% decline confirmed in primary sources for any recent one-year period.
Model consensus 1 of 4 agree · 3 dissents
anthropic
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

DHS stated in a September 30, 2025 release that 'since President Trump took office, fentanyl trafficking at the southern border is down by 56% compared to the same period in 2024.' WOLA's analysis of CBP fiscal year 2025 data shows fentanyl seizures dropped 46% from 2024 and 57% from 2023, broadly consistent with a roughly 56% drop in the relevant comparison period. However, the figure refers to fentanyl seizures (an imperfect proxy for actual flow), not direct measurements of trafficking. Whether this is 'a record' decline is plausible given fentanyl seizures are at the lowest level since 2021, but the framing as the actual 'flow' rather than seizures is somewhat misleading.

openai
❌ False
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 4.1.2025.04.14

CBP fentanyl seizure data show that the amount of fentanyl seized at the border has generally increased year-over-year. There is no record of a 56% annual decline; in fact, 2023 set new records for seizures. The claim of a record drop is contradicted by the data.

gemini
❓ Unverifiable
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

Official data from U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) on fentanyl seizures is necessary to verify this claim, but a complete dataset for the specified timeframe (the year preceding February 24, 2026) is not available. While some secondary sources and press releases from 2025 allude to a 56% decrease in fentanyl trafficking compared to 2024, this cannot be independently confirmed with primary source data from CBP's statistical dashboards, which do not yet provide a full, finalized comparison for this period. Seizure amounts fluctuate significantly month-to-month, and full fiscal year data would be needed for an accurate assessment.

xai
📊 Exaggerated
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

CBP reports fluctuations in fentanyl seizures, with some periods showing declines, but a 56% reduction in flow is not directly supported; seizures increased overall in recent years (e.g., record highs in 2023-2024), and flow estimates are indirect, making the 'record' claim overstated.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 04 / 10 False
"Trump claims that in the last three months of 2025, core inflation was down to 1.7 percent."
statistical
Model notes
  • AnthropicBLS October 2025 CPI was disrupted by a lapse in appropriations, so some monthly readings were nowcast rather than directly measured; however, Q4 2025 and December year-over-year core PCE and core CPI figures are available and uniformly well above 1.7%.
  • OpenAITier 1 primary sources were retrieved and used. One nuance is that 'core inflation' can refer to either core CPI or core PCE, but neither official measure is anywhere near 1.7% for late 2025. In addition, BLS did not publish an October 2025 core CPI estimate because of the appropriations lapse.
  • Grok 4No complete Tier 1 primary source retrieved despite relevant domain due to 2025 appropriations lapse affecting October and November data; verdict rests on secondary analysis and later data releases from sources like FRED and fact-checks dated March 2026.
Model consensus 3 of 4 agree · 1 dissent
anthropic
❌ False
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

Trump's claim that core inflation was 1.7% in the last three months of 2025 is contradicted by primary and secondary data from the speech-era window. According to BEA data reported on Feb 20, 2026, core PCE — the Fed's preferred gauge — accelerated to 3.0% year-over-year in December 2025 (up from 2.8% in November), and on a Q4/Q4 basis core PCE rose 2.9% in Q4 2025. Core CPI was even higher: the US Inflation Calculator, citing BLS, reports the core CPI rate for December 2025 was 3.6% year-over-year, with a 2.8% average for 2025. Even on alternative bases (3-month annualized, trimmed mean), no mainstream measure for Oct–Dec 2025 came near 1.7%; core PCE MoM in December 2025 was 0.4% (roughly 4.8% annualized). The 1.7% figure does not match any standard core inflation reading for Q4 2025.

openai
❌ False
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 5.4.2026.03.05

Primary federal inflation sources do not support Trump’s February 24, 2026 claim. For the last available months of 2025, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported U.S. CPI 'all items less food and energy' (core CPI) up 2.6% year-over-year in November 2025 and 2.7% year-over-year in December 2025, not 1.7%. The Bureau of Economic Analysis likewise reported core PCE inflation at 3.0% year-over-year in December 2025. BLS also states that it did not publish an October 2025 all-items-less-food-and-energy estimate because of the 2025 lapse in appropriations, so there is no official October 2025 core CPI reading that could make 'the last three months of 2025' equal 1.7%. Given the official 2025 data points dated December 18, 2025 (for November CPI), January 13, 2026 (for December CPI), and January 30, 2026 (for December PCE), the claim is contradicted by the relevant speech-era evidence.

gemini
❌ False
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

Official data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) shows the year-over-year core inflation rate was 2.6% in both November and December 2025. [1, 2] The BLS did not collect or report CPI data for October 2025 due to a lapse in federal appropriations. [2, 23] There is no publicly available data from the BLS that supports the claim that core inflation was down to 1.7% during the last three months of 2025; the actual reported figures were significantly higher.

xai
✅ True
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

The claim refers to the three-month annualized core inflation rate (CPI excluding food and energy) for October to December 2025, which was approximately 1.7% according to fact-checking sources and available data from December 2025. While primary BLS reports note missing data for October and November 2025 due to a government appropriations lapse, later analyses and backfilled data confirm the rate dropped to this level, marking the lowest since early 2021.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 05 / 10 True
"Trump claims gasoline reached a peak of over $6 a gallon in some states under his predecessor (Biden)."
statistical
Model consensus 3 of 4 agree · 1 dissent
anthropic
✅ True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

AAA data confirm that during Joe Biden's presidency, California's average gas price reached $6.43 per gallon on June 14, 2022, well above $6/gallon. The national average peaked at about $5.02 in mid-June 2022 (with weekly highs around $5.11), and several Western states saw averages exceeding $6, including Hawaii and California. So Trump's claim that gasoline reached over $6 per gallon in some states under Biden is accurate.

openai
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 4.1.2025.04.14

According to the Energy Information Administration (EIA) and AAA, during 2022 the average U.S. retail gasoline price peaked near $5 per gallon nationally, but in California prices exceeded $6 per gallon at their highest point, reaching $6.44 in June 2022. This was under President Biden, aligning with Trump's claim regarding some states.

gemini
✅ True
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

During the Biden administration, average prices for regular unleaded gasoline did exceed $6 per gallon in some states. Data from AAA and other sources show that in June 2022, the average price in California surpassed this mark, reaching a record high of $6.44.

xai
✅ True
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

EIA data confirms that under the Biden administration (2021-2024), retail gasoline prices peaked over $6 per gallon in some states, notably California where prices reached up to $6.44 in June 2022, amid national averages hitting $5.006, driven by high crude oil prices and regional factors.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 06 / 10 True
"The 250th anniversary of American independence will occur less than five months from February 24, 2026, on July 4, 2026."
historical
Model consensus 4 of 4 agree
anthropic
✅ True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

The 250th anniversary of American independence (the Declaration of Independence was signed July 4, 1776) falls on July 4, 2026. From February 24, 2026, that is approximately 4 months and 10 days away — less than five months. Trump himself stated 'Less than five months from now, our country will celebrate an epic milestone in American history, the 250th anniversary of our glorious American independence' and that 'This July 4th, we will mark two and a half centuries.' The mathematical and historical facts confirm the claim.

openai
✅ True
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 5.4

The claim is correct. The National Park Service states that the United States will celebrate the 250th anniversary of American independence in 2026, with events specifically marked for Saturday, July 4, 2026. From the speech date of February 24, 2026, to July 4, 2026, is 130 days—about 4 months and 10 days—so it is indeed less than five months away.

gemini
✅ True
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

The United States Declaration of Independence was signed on July 4, 1776. The 250th anniversary, also known as the Semiquincentennial, will therefore be on July 4, 2026. The period from the speech date of February 24, 2026, to July 4, 2026, is approximately four months and ten days, which is correctly described as "less than five months."

xai
✅ True
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

The Declaration of Independence was signed on July 4, 1776, making July 4, 2026, the 250th anniversary. The period from February 24, 2026, to July 4, 2026, is approximately 4 months and 10 days, which is less than five months, as confirmed by multiple sources including the U.S. Department of State and Wikipedia entries dated around 2026.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 07 / 10 False
"Trump claims that when he last spoke in the chamber 12 months prior (approximately February 2025), he had inherited a nation with inflation at record levels."
statistical
Model notes
  • OpenAIPrimary-source Tier 1 evidence retrieved from BLS. The claim uses vague rhetoric ('record levels'), but under any ordinary reading of U.S. CPI records it is not supportable.
  • GoogleNo Tier 1 primary source retrieved despite relevant domain; verdict rests on secondary analysis of BLS data.
Model consensus 4 of 4 agree
anthropic
❌ False
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

Trump's claim that he inherited inflation 'at record levels' when he took office in January 2025 is false. On an annual basis, inflation when Trump took office was 2.9%, which isn't a record high level. Recent record inflation was experienced in 2022, when it hit 8.9%. The highest inflation ever experienced happened in the 1980s, when it reached as high as around 14%. Inflation reached a four-decade high of 9.1% in 2022 after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. By the time President Joe Biden left office, inflation had fallen to 3%. Inflation was around 3% — far from a record high — when Trump was inaugurated.

openai
❌ False
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 5.4

At the time Trump was speaking about what he had inherited around February 2025, inflation was not at record levels. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported on February 12, 2025, that the January 2025 CPI was up 3.0% year over year. That is elevated relative to the Federal Reserve’s 2% target, but nowhere near the modern U.S. record highs seen in 2022, when CPI inflation peaked around 9.1% year over year in June 2022. So describing the inherited inflation situation in early 2025 as being at “record levels” is contradicted by BLS data aligned to that term and date.

gemini
❌ False
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

Donald Trump's second term began in January 2025. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and reports citing its data, the annual inflation rate (CPI) was 3.0% in January 2025 and fell to 2.8% in February 2025. These figures are not record levels. The highest recorded inflation rate in U.S. history was 23.7% in June 1920, with other peaks of 20.1% in 1947 and 14.8% in 1980. Even the more recent peak was 9.1% in June 2022, more than triple the rate in early 2025.

xai
❌ False
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

BLS data for January and February 2025 shows the CPI-U increased by 3.0% from January 2024 to January 2025 and 2.8% from February 2024 to February 2025, which are not record levels; historical record highs were around 14.8% in March 1980, and recent peaks were 9.1% in June 2022, making the inherited inflation rates relatively moderate rather than at record highs.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 08 / 10 Models split
"Trump claims that last year, the murder rate saw its single largest decline in recorded history."
statistical
Model notes
  • AnthropicOfficial FBI 2025 data not yet released as of speech date; verdict relies on preliminary estimates from CCJ and 2024 FBI data.
  • OpenAIPrimary-source Tier 1-style federal law-enforcement evidence retrieved from FBI. Caveat: the FBI release cited here refers to murder and non-negligent manslaughter estimates, not a separately stated long-run 'murder rate' series in the snippet; wording about 'recorded history' is therefore accepted with modest caution.
  • GoogleThe claim was made in February 2026, before final, official national crime statistics for 2025 would have been released by the FBI. The verdict is based on preliminary data and expert analysis from major cities, which was widely reported at the time.
  • Grok 4No Tier 1 primary source retrieved from fbi.gov for 2025 data despite relevant domain; verdict rests on secondary analysis from news outlets and research organizations using preliminary data.
Model consensus 2 of 4 agree · 2 dissents
anthropic
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

FBI data show the national murder rate recorded the largest one-year decline in homicides, down 14.9 percent from 2023 to 2024, with back-to-back years of historic declines after the murder rate declined by 10 percent from 2022 to 2023. However, Trump in his February 2026 speech was likely referring to 2025 (the year his administration was in office). Over the past three years, homicides have fallen by an average of 16% per year, including a 21% drop from 2024 to 2025 in a sample of 35 large cities, suggesting the U.S. homicide rate in 2025 would be the lowest observed since at least 1900. Independent researchers' preliminary estimates support a historic decline; preliminary data suggests that homicides may have hit a 125-year low last year, although the FBI's official annual crime report for 2025 will not be released until later this year. The FBI's 2024 data already showed the largest one-year decline ever recorded; whether 2025 surpassed that remains preliminary.

openai
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 5.4

The best available primary evidence supports the substance of the claim, with some caution about wording. The FBI reported on August 5, 2025, that murder and non-negligent manslaughter in 2024 fell 14.9% from 2023. The FBI had separately reported on September 23, 2024, that the 2023 murder rate fell 11.6% from 2022. Among the FBI declines surfaced here, the 2024 drop is larger, supporting Trump's statement that the prior year saw the biggest recorded decline. However, because the claim says 'murder rate' while the FBI release is framed as estimated murder offenses, and because historical-record formulations can depend on dataset definitions and revisions, the safest verdict is Mostly True rather than fully categorical True.

gemini
✅ True
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

The claim refers to the calendar year 2025. Based on preliminary data available in early 2026, multiple analyses confirmed the assertion. A January 2026 report from the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ), based on data from dozens of large U.S. cities, found that homicides dropped by approximately 21% in 2025 compared to 2024. News outlets and crime data analysts reporting on this data described it as the "single-largest one-year drop on record" and "by far the largest decline ever recorded".

xai
✅ True
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

Multiple reports from 2026, including from the Council on Criminal Justice, CBS News, BBC, and The New York Times, confirm that the U.S. homicide rate declined by approximately 20-21% in 2025 compared to 2024, marking the largest single-year drop in recorded history, with data covering periods up to December 2025.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 09 / 10 Truthy
"Trump claims the murder rate is at the lowest number in over 125 years, specifically referencing the year 1900."
statistical
Model notes
  • AnthropicBased on Council on Criminal Justice projections from large-city samples; final FBI 2025 data was not yet available at speech time.
  • OpenAITier 1 federal sources were searched and relevant CDC/FBI material was found, but no retrieved source in this call provided the necessary continuous 1900-to-2024 comparison. Verdict therefore rests on insufficient retrieved evidence, not a positive confirmation.
  • GoogleThe claim was made in February 2026, before final, official national crime statistics for 2025 would have been released by the FBI. The verdict is based on preliminary data and expert analysis from major cities, which was widely reported at the time.
  • Grok 4No Tier 1 primary source retrieved from fbi.gov for 2025/2026 data despite relevant domain; verdict rests on secondary analysis; data primarily covers 2025, with limited insight into early 2026.
Model consensus 2 of 4 agree · 2 dissents
anthropic
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

Independent researcher analyses support this claim with caveats about preliminary data. If a similar decline is reflected in national data, the U.S. homicide rate in 2025 would be the lowest observed since at least 1900. Applying a 20% decline from 2024 to 2025 suggests a national homicide rate of 4.0 per 100,000 residents in 2025, eclipsing the previous historic low of 4.4 per 100,000 recorded in 2014. Preliminary data from independent researchers suggests that homicides may have hit a 125-year low last year, although the FBI's official annual crime report for 2025 will not be released until later this year. A January study by the Council on Criminal Justice found a 'strong possibility' that the 2025 homicide rate will drop to about 4 per 100,000 residents, which would be the lowest recorded in law enforcement or public health data dating back to 1900. The claim is directionally correct but rests on preliminary projections, not confirmed FBI data.

openai
❓ Unverifiable
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 5.4

The retrieved federal sources do not substantiate the precise claim that the U.S. murder rate is at its lowest level in more than 125 years, i.e. since 1900. The FBI’s 2024 national crime release shows a large recent drop in murder offenses, and CDC pages retrieved here show current homicide mortality resources, including a FastStats figure of 4.5 deaths per 100,000 based on 2024 mortality data. But the sources retrieved in this search do not provide a continuous nationally comparable series back to 1900 that would allow confirming the 'lowest since 1900' assertion. Without that long-run primary series in hand, the specific historical comparison cannot be verified from the evidence retrieved.

gemini
✅ True
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

This claim is based on expert analysis of preliminary 2025 crime data that was available at the time of the speech in February 2026. A January 2026 report from the Council on Criminal Justice projected that the national homicide rate for 2025 would be approximately 4.0 per 100,000 residents. This would be lower than any previously recorded rate, including the prior lows of 4.4 per 100,000, and would represent the lowest rate since at least 1900. News reports and analyses from the period widely corroborated this finding.

xai
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

Reports from early 2026, such as from Axios, BBC, and Fox News, indicate that the U.S. murder rate in 2025 reached its lowest level since 1900 at approximately 4.29 per 100,000 people; however, the claim refers to the rate in February 2026, and while trends suggest continuation, full 2026 data is not yet available, making the statement accurate for the most recent complete year but slightly premature for 2026.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC
Claim 10 / 10 Truthy
"Trump claims his administration has driven core inflation down to the lowest level in more than five years within 12 months."
statistical
Model notes
  • AnthropicCore inflation at a 5-year low is essentially accurate for January 2026, but the related '1.7%' three-month figure is questionable due to the BLS October 2025 data gap from the government shutdown.
  • OpenAIPrimary-source Tier 1 evidence retrieved from BLS. The numerical part of the claim is supported, but causation ('driven') is inherently more interpretive than the inflation readings themselves.
  • GoogleNo single Tier 1 primary source URL was retrieved that contained the full historical dataset from 2021-2026 in a single view. The verdict is synthesized from multiple secondary reports and BLS press releases covering different time periods.
  • Grok 4Initial Tier 1 search on bls.gov returned general CPI data but not specific core rates; verdict based on secondary sources providing detailed core inflation figures.
Model consensus 3 of 4 agree · 1 dissent
anthropic
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Anthropic Claude Opus 4.7

The core CPI claim is technically supportable for the January 2026 reading. The CPI rose 2.4% in January from a year earlier, down from 2.7% in December. Excluding food and energy, the core CPI was up 2.5%, the lowest level since April 2021. Core inflation was 2.5% in January 2026, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, the lowest since 1.6% in March 2021 – nearly five years ago. So core inflation is at roughly a five-year low (just under five years from April 2021 to January 2026). However, fact-checkers note nuance: while it's true that inflation has eased in recent months, federal data does not show as dramatic a decline as Trump has claimed. Trump's accompanying claim that core inflation was 1.7% in the last three months of 2025 is disputed: core inflation was 2.6 percent in both November and December and 2.5 percent in January — down from 3.3 percent in January 2025. Trump cited the last three months of 2025, which would have included October, but BLS did not release a figure for October because of the government shutdown.

openai
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — OpenAI GPT 5.4

Primary BLS data support the broad claim. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that core CPI ('all items less food and energy') was 2.5% year over year in January 2026 and again 2.5% in February 2026. That is the lowest core inflation rate in more than five years, because by early 2021 core CPI had already moved above that level and then remained higher through the 2021-2025 inflation surge. So within roughly 12 months of taking office on January 20, 2025, core inflation had fallen to a five-plus-year low. The nuance is that saying his administration 'drove' it down assigns full causal credit to the administration for a trend the data alone do not prove was caused solely by White House policy.

gemini
🟢 Mostly True
Model reasoning — Google Gemini 2.5 Pro

According to reports citing the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), the annual core inflation rate, which excludes food and energy, was 2.5% in February 2026. This was a decrease from the 3.1% rate reported by the BLS for the 12 months ending in February 2025, confirming that core inflation was driven down during the first year of the second Trump administration. However, the claim that this is the lowest level in "more than five years" is a slight exaggeration. The 2.5% rate was widely reported as the lowest since March 2021, which is 4 years and 11 months prior to the speech, just shy of the five-year mark.

xai
❌ False
Model reasoning — Xai Grok 4

Core inflation data from sources like Trading Economics and US Inflation Calculator show rates around 2.5-2.6% in February and March 2026, but these are not the lowest in more than five years, as rates were lower in early 2021 (e.g., 1.3% in February 2021) and in 2020; the administration may have reduced inflation from 2025 levels (around 2.8%), but the claim overstates the achievement relative to the past five years, with data up to March 2026.

Combined evidence / sources list
↑ Back to claim list · ↑ Top of page Last verified 2026-04-30 00:27 UTC